If We All Speak English, Why Don’t We All Sound Alike? Robert MacNeil’s Exploration of Language

Many people think English should be the official language of the United States. President Trump is trying to make it so, through an executive order.

But even if everyone spoke English that doesn’t mean we all sound alike. A native of Pittsburgh is going to sound different than a native of New Orleans, or Boston or Omaha.

It may seem like the regional differences in our language have become blurred over the decades, due to the influence of television and the media.

Get your copy of Robert MacNeil’s book

But experts say that’s not necessarily true.

And here’s where former PBS TV anchorman Robert MacNeil comes in. Back in 1986 MacNeil was co-author of a book, and companion TV series, called The Story of English.

And in 2005 he took it a step further, with a new book called Do You Speak American? That book was a detailed exploration of how regional dialects and accents continue to flourish.

I had gotten to know Robert MacNeil over the years, always looking up to him as a fellow broadcaster. We met one day in January of 2005 to talk about his new book.

So here now, from 2005, Robert MacNeil.

Robert MacNeil died in 2024. He was 93.

Mignon Fogarty

Photo: Kyle David Jones

Do you know how hard it is to interview someone who you know will be assessing every sentence that comes out of your mouth?

I hadn’t been so self-conscious since I interviewed William F. Buckley, but it turns out, Mignon Fogarty was much nicer than what I’d feared. When I talked with her in 2009 about her books and podcast, she was nothing but cordial. And forgiving.

Since 2006 Mignon Fogarty has produced and hosted the “Grammar Girl” podcast. Who would’ve guessed that the nation was full of people so enchanted by .. grammar.

Indeed, proper language usage means a lot to many people. If you doubt me, just make a usage mistake on social media and watch how many of your “friends” will correct you.

So here now, from 2009, Grammar Girl Mignon Fogarty.


You may also like these episodes:

Neil de Greasse Tyson
Peggy Noonan

Buy Books / Media from Amazon